Results 1 to 7 of 7

Thread: comments deleted

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    2,633
    Thanks Given
    626
    Thanks Received
    15,169
    Thanked in
    2,929 Posts

    comments deleted

    I posted some appreciative words of praise about a post yesterday, not long just a few words to say thanks and welcome a new faker to the board. Apparently the post was deleted. WHY. Have we now reached the stage where only the mods can interject a comment in a post? I would really like to know why my post was taken down. I understand we don't want long stretches of meaningless posts without pictures but this was not, nor was it anymore then what goes on all the time.

  2. # ADS
    Join Date
    Always
    Posts
    Many
     
  3. #2
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    875
    Thanks Given
    12,069
    Thanks Received
    5,669
    Thanked in
    856 Posts

    Re: comments deleted

    Quote Originally Posted by vdat100
    I posted some appreciative words of praise about a post yesterday, not long just a few words to say thanks and welcome a new faker to the board. Apparently the post was deleted. WHY. Have we now reached the stage where only the mods can interject a comment in a post? I would really like to know why my post was taken down. I understand we don't want long stretches of meaningless posts without pictures but this was not, nor was it anymore then what goes on all the time.
    Is the fake you commented on still posted Vdat?

  4. #3
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    2,633
    Thanks Given
    626
    Thanks Received
    15,169
    Thanked in
    2,929 Posts

    Re: comments deleted

    Quote Originally Posted by Newton
    Quote Originally Posted by vdat100
    I posted some appreciative words of praise about a post yesterday, not long just a few words to say thanks and welcome a new faker to the board. Apparently the post was deleted. WHY. Have we now reached the stage where only the mods can interject a comment in a post? I would really like to know why my post was taken down. I understand we don't want long stretches of meaningless posts without pictures but this was not, nor was it anymore then what goes on all the time.
    Is the fake you commented on still posted Vdat?
    yes they are

  5. #4
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    UK
    Posts
    6,802
    Thanks Given
    3,996
    Thanks Received
    11,231
    Thanked in
    5,010 Posts

    Re: comments deleted

    Quote Originally Posted by vdat100
    I posted some appreciative words of praise about a post yesterday, not long just a few words to say thanks and welcome a new faker to the board. Apparently the post was deleted. WHY. Have we now reached the stage where only the mods can interject a comment in a post? I would really like to know why my post was taken down. I understand we don't want long stretches of meaningless posts without pictures but this was not, nor was it anymore then what goes on all the time.
    Usually we allow about six months for a Ty post to remain.
    One of the main jobs we Mods carry out is going thro threads and weeding out old
    Ty & emoticon posts. The reason being that our hard drive gets filled up and probs
    start occurring..such as the recent crash.
    As your complaint is of a recent post I can only think that an over zealous Mod just
    blindly deleted it as he went about his chores.
    Perhaps if you could give us more chapter and verse we may identify who did it and why.
    My own practise is to publish a pic with my comment...Mods do not delete posts containing
    pics.
    Please do not assume that our purpose is to annoy members....we are fallible.

  6. #5
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    2,633
    Thanks Given
    626
    Thanks Received
    15,169
    Thanked in
    2,929 Posts

    Re: comments deleted

    Quote Originally Posted by spike70
    Quote Originally Posted by vdat100
    I posted some appreciative words of praise about a post yesterday, not long just a few words to say thanks and welcome a new faker to the board. Apparently the post was deleted. WHY. Have we now reached the stage where only the mods can interject a comment in a post? I would really like to know why my post was taken down. I understand we don't want long stretches of meaningless posts without pictures but this was not, nor was it anymore then what goes on all the time.
    Usually we allow about six months for a Ty post to remain.
    One of the main jobs we Mods carry out is going thro threads and weeding out old
    Ty & emoticon posts. The reason being that our hard drive gets filled up and probs
    start occurring..such as the recent crash.
    As your complaint is of a recent post I can only think that an over zealous Mod just
    blindly deleted it as he went about his chores.
    Perhaps if you could give us more chapter and verse we may identify who did it and why.
    My own practise is to publish a pic with my comment...Mods do not delete posts containing
    pics.
    Please do not assume that our purpose is to annoy members....we are fallible.
    thanks for the explanation spike. i will post my comments again lets see what happens.

  7. #6
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    UK
    Posts
    24,779
    Thanks Given
    13,966
    Thanks Received
    48,724
    Thanked in
    19,120 Posts
    As a quick rule of thumb, if you want your post to last:
    a) Add a picture - rarely do picture posts get deleted.
    b) failing that, steer clear of the "Wow, thanks" type posts, as Spike says, after a few months they get dumped.
    Try some constructive encouragement. Tell the poster why you like it, "Big Tits" ain't gonna do it.
    c) Don't post a smilie only reply, these get deleted as soon as we spot them. Repeat offenders will also get a warning.

    Long winded conversations between a couple of posters is frowned upon too, use the PM system if you want to have a chat.

  8. #7
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    791
    Thanks Given
    3,783
    Thanks Received
    374
    Thanked in
    99 Posts

    Re: comments deleted

    well i didn't delete it or i would have PM'ed you unless it was the type of post that spike mentioned. even then, we usually let them go for a period of time.

    Quote Originally Posted by vdat100
    Have we now reached the stage where only the mods can interject a comment in a post?
    apparently you have never been aware that mods have always been able to/done this.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions